Jasper County, Illinois
Genealogy Trails logo
Genealogy and History

Crime News

Horse Thieves.
On the night of the 16th, Mr. Denman, near Hidalgo, Jasper county, lost five horses; and on the Tuesday following Orville Wilhoit, of Coles county, lost four. R. Rankins, of Marshall, Clark county, lost one. Two persons were arrested at Westfield on suspicion of being engaged in the theft.   [Sangamo Journal / Illinois State Journal - 26 November 1856]

Edward Forsman was pardoned out of the penitentiary by Gov. Altgeld.  He was sent from Jasper county in 1887 for 14 years for murder.  [True Republican, 13 February 1895]

Newton, Ill., Jan 9 — Particulars of a mail robbery which occurred about December 23 have just leaked out here after being kept quiet by the post office authorities for several days. December 24 the track walker on the Ohio At Mississippi railroad saw four men sitting by a fire near Clay City, who, on his approach, made their escape, leaving a large number of rifled letters containing checks, drafts and other papers, some of which had been sent from the People's bank, of this place. The supposition is that a mail pouch has been stolen from some of the transfer stations. All the letters and papers are in possession of Sheriff Higgins of Olney, Ill., who is awaiting the arrival of the post-office inspector.
[The Evening Bulletin., January 09, 1889, (Maysville, Ky.)]

Fred Hollinger, collector of Wade township, Jasper county, Ills., has been missing for a week, and is short in his accounts $1,000. [The Argus. (Rock Island, Ill.), 28 June 1886.]

Newton's Ben Blanchard
The Joseph Litzelman, mentioned in the Gazette of last week is a nephew of the proprietor of the American House in Newton.  The Cumberland Times says:
Joseph C. Litzelman, a Newton, Ill., contractor, has disappeared between two days, leaving behind him scores of victims who hold nothing but his forged paper.  Litzelman recently has been engaged in buying and selling railroad ties to the Peoria, Decatur and Evansville railroad.  He also bought up staves and hoops in large quantities, and his transactions made it necessary to handle large sums of money, which he generally raised on forged notes.  Many of his speculations, however, proved unprofitable, and he soon found himself in a bad financial condition.  Having a circle of well-to-do relatives, he never failed to use their names to paper on which he desired to realize money.  The Litzelmans are among the wealthiest people of Jasper county, and their signatures would be weighty in almost any bank in the southern part of the state.  Young Joseph, knowing this, never failed to use the name of his father, and when that failed to accomplish the desired effect he would add the name of his uncle, Joseph Litzelman, proprietor of the American Hotel, at Newton.
The forger bought a $2,000 residence with forged paper, and came into possession of a barber shop and property by the same methods.  His mode of doing business was always considered by practical business men as very reckless, but it was not until within two or three weeks prior to his departure that the people became suspicious of his actions.  ONly a few days before his departure he called on the bank in Effingham for a loan of $2,000, offering George and Anthony Litzelman as security.  The Effingham bank wrote a letter of inquiry to the Newton bank, and got a reply from Cashier Scott which, in substance, was to the effect that the note was probably a forgery.  Litzelman, however, smelled a mouse, and carrying previous plans into execution escaped before the stern hand of the law could be laid on him.
Among the victimized ones Litzelman leaves behind him forged papers are Daniel Wood. $1800;  Jerry S. Kelton, $25; Schifferstein & Osthermeier, $500; Thos. W. Wheeler, $300; Joseph Boas, $110; Dr. A.A. Frank, $110;  Taylor Randolph, $280; Wash Kibler, $200; John M. Foltz, $225; James Kelly, $100; W.H. England, $61.
The above is only a partial list of those who succumbed to the wiles of the sleek forger, and it is expected that another batch will be brought to the surface in a few days.  The man's own relatives have turned against him and declare that they had never, in all of his railroad transactions, signed his paper in a single instance.  Litzelman enjoyed an enviable reputation in his community and his acquaintances reposed the utmost confidence in him.  He had an unassuming air and innocent cast of countenance.  It is predicted that the total amount of his forgeries will reach about $10,000.  He leaves his family in destitute circumstances.[Mattoon Gazette (Mattoon, Illinois) 8 Jan 1886, Friday]

Four Convicted of Holy Beating
Two Boys are Badly Hurt as Result of Effort to Exorcise the Devil -- Mob Violence is Feared -- Several Attacks Made on Defendants in the Courtroom at Newton, Illinois
Newton, Ill., Feb 18 - Four members of the Holiness sect are in the Jasper county Jail under heavy guard to prevent mob violence as the result of disclosures made in court yesterday when the quartet was convicted of having severely beaten two young boys at their church on Sunday. The sheriff swore in a posse to protect the defendants when spectators in the court room attempted to attack them while the trial was in progress. The hearing was interrupted several times when the crowd rushed on the defendants, kicked and beat them, and attempted to do further damage to the preacher, the chief of the defendants. Yesterday's trial was the second to which the defendants have submitted. The first was held Monday and the four were convicted and fined $100 and costs. Yesterday's hearing resulted in the same penalty. Today action will be brought against all those who were in the church on Sunday. The defendants will number a score or more.
Forgotten Lessons Cause Beating.
Those who were convicted were P. D. Lyons, the Holiness preacher; Cameron and Frank Cummins, who are well to do farmers, and Mrs. Emma Vantress. The boys who were beaten were Cameron Cummins Richardson, aged 9, and Raymond Richardson, aged 11. They are nephews of the two Cummins men and of Mrs. Vantress.
According to the testimony the boys, whose home is in Pacific, Mo., had been unable to repeat lessons which had been given them for recitation at the meeting of the Holiness congregation in the chapel southeast of here. It was accordingly decided by the congregation that they were possessed of the devil and that he should be beaten out of them. They were tied hand and foot and placed on the floor and three men applied a whip which was half an inch in diameter. The members of the sect gathered around and prayed constantly that the whipping might hasten the departure of the evil one.   The chastisement started at 9 o'clock in the morning and was continued with only a few minutes' stop nearly all day. The stop was taken to permit a stranger to pass. Then the boys were put to bed without any medical attention.
Boys Are Seriously Injured.
The effect of the lashings was shown when the boys' backs were exhibited in the court room. They were slashed and cut in all directions and both boys were in such physical condition that they could hardly move a muscle. Their condition was made worse by the fact that they had been forced to undergo several fasts to starve out the devil before it was decided to beat him out. When called on to testify the preacher started to deliver a long sermon, but was forbidden by the court. His defense was that the Bible said to whip with a rod and that he was doing his duty by his actions. The boys' mother, a convert to the sect, arrived from Missouri and testified for the defendants.  [Rock Island Argus. (Rock Island, Ill.), 18 Feb. 1914]

W.E. Stone, sentenced to state prison for seven years for forgery, escaped from jail at Newton, Ills., Friday, while the streets were full of people.  [The Rock Island Argus, 24 May 1890]

The second trial of Floyd Worthey for the murder of his brother-in-law, Robert Alcoke, in South Muddy Township, Jasper county, last October, has been set for next April in the Jasper county Circuit Court at Newton. At the first trial last January Floyd Worthey was found guilty of manslaughter, and the jury fixed the penalty at 14 years in the penitentiary. Sentence, however, was withheld to give him an opportunity to apply for a new trial, which he immediately asked for, and was admitted to bail in the sum of $25,000. His father, Charles Worthey, who was tried at the same crime for murder of Alcoke, was acquitted. Recently, Charles Worthey has been joined at the home place by another son, Herbert Worthey, who has lived in Chicago for several years. Herbert Worthey is a widower, his wife having died in Chicago several years ago.[Source: "The Flora Journal-Record" (Clay Co., Ill.) 12 February 1925]

The burning of the Springs Holiness church near Newton, Illinois, Thursday was the outcome of a fierce outburst of mob violence against fanatical "Holy Rollers," who attempt to beat sin and the devil out of two boys of 9 and 10 years of age.  Those found guilty in court of the attack, which took place in the church, were heavily fined.  [Deming Graphic. (Deming, N.M.), 27 Feb. 1914]



©K. Torp and Genealogy Trails