Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society
Vol. 14, April -
July, 1921, No. 1-2, Vol. XIV, No. 1
OLD COURT HOUSE IN METAMORA
AS STATE LINCOLN
Ex-Governor Joseph W. Fifer in Dedicatory
(Copied largely from Metamora Herald, August 26, 1921.)
official transfer of the old Metamora court house to the State of
Illinois, to be preserved for the ages as a Lincoln Memorial Museum, was
celebrated by Metamora in connection with the annual Woodford County Old
Settlers' reunion, and thus the occasion was made a noteworthy
By action of the last session of the legislature the State
accepted the offer of the village of Metamora to deed the historic old
building entire and unconditionally to its care. Former Governor Joseph W.
Fifer, in the absence of State Senator Simon E. Lantz, appearing as the
representative of the State, received from Mayor J. C. Snyder the deed to
Ex-Governor Joseph W. Fifer of Bloomington, who one
year ago at the Old Settlers' picnic in Metamora set in motion the project
of the State of Illinois taking charge of the building, delivered the
dedicatory address. Governor Fifer, in his address last year, pointed out
that the old building is the last remaining court house in the state in
which Abraham Lincoln practiced law and he pledged that he would endeavor
to enlist the support of the governor and legislators in an official move
to preserve the old court house.
Senator Simon E. Lantz took up the
matter and introduced a bill in the last assembly, which he successfully
put through the senate, and Representatives Charles E. Turner, Michael
Fahy and D. S. Myers pushed the bill through the house, during the closing
days of the session, and it was duly signed by Governor
Has an Interesting History
A halo of
interesting history clusters around the venerated old structure. It was
built in 1845 by David Irving, father of J. C. Irving of Metamora, from
native burned brick and lime and hardwood lumber sawed from the virgin
forest. Abraham Lincoln, as a circuit riding lawyer, had been attending
court in Old Versailles, the first county seat of Woodford county, and on
the removal of the county seat to Metamora he continued to ride the
circuit with the presiding judge and the other lawyers from one county
seat to another. He was a regular attendant at court in Metamora, except
possibly during the sessions of the legislature of which he was a member
for several years, and continued to ride the circuit until the late
fifties. There are still a few people living who saw Lincoln in the actual
trial of cases in the old court room on the second floor. Other men of
prominence who attended court in the old building were Judge David Davis,
who afterward became a justice of the United States Supreme Court; Adlai
E. Stevenson, who practiced law in Metamora for ten years and afterward
became Vice President of the United States; Robert G. Ingersoll, who
though an agnostic was one of the most scholarly men of his day: and there
are others who achieved state and nation-wide fame.
building had served as the Woodford county court house for half a century,
when in 1896 an election changed the county seat to Eureka. Upon the
building of the new court house the old building was deeded to the village
of Metamora. It has been used as a village hall, board meeting place,
etc., and has been kept in a fair state of repair. A year ago the village
turned the old court room over to the Metamora post of the American Legion
as a meeting place and the post has kept the upper rooms in presentable
shape. The day was not far distant when more extensive repairs would be
needed if the old building was to be preserved and the village welcomed
the suggestion that the state assume ownership and care of the
To Be Lincoln Museum.
At a recent
conference between Colonel C. R. Miller of the State Department of Public
Works and Buildings, Senator Simon E. Lantz and a local committee
appointed by Mayor Snyder, the plan was agreed upon to make of the
building a Lincoln museum, gathering together local mementoes of Lincoln
and articles of pioneer life and placing a competent care-taker in charge.
This matter will be taken up at once after the formal transfer of the
Old Settlers' Reunion.
the big feature of the day the annual reunion of the Old Settlers of
Woodford county takes place. The day's program opened with a band concert
at 9 o'clock in the morning by Elgin's band of Peoria, and at 10:30 the
annual Old Settlers' session was held. The amusements during the morning
hours were a horse-shoe tournament between the Woodford county team and
teams representing surrounding counties in this part of the State and a
ball game. At the high school ball grounds the Washington Liberties and
Metamora staged a game at 10 a.m.
Between 12:30 and 1:30 Mark Arnold, daredevil aerial
performer, made ascensions. Airplane passengers were carried during
Great Program Afternoon.
gave a half hour's concert from 1:30 to 2:00 o'clock and the dedication
program began promptly at 2:00 o'clock. Ex-Governor Fifer gave an
historical address dedicating the old court house to the State.
Immediately there-after Mayor Snyder presented the deed to the property to
Governor Fifer, who made a short address of acceptance. Hon. Frank
Gillespie, brilliant Bloomington attorney and orator, delivered the annual
address to the Old Settlers, and short informal talks followed by
Representatives Turner, Fahy and Myers, and by visiting Old Settlers.
THOUSANDS ATTEND HISTORICAL EVENT.
Transfer of Old
Metamora Court House to State
Has Great Setting.
Connection With Annual Reunion of Old Settlers
Results in One of
Biggest Days of Metamora's History.
As the days of more than half a
century ago when Lincoln and Douglas made campaign speeches in Metamora,
when the first train went through the town or when a great barbecue was
given at the close of the Civil War, have been often referred to as
Metamora's biggest days, so the occasion of the transfer of the old
Metamora court house to the State of Illinois, to become known throughout
the Union as the "Lincoln Memorial Court House at Metamora," will be
recounted by the present generation in the years to come.
dedication, held in connection with the annual Woodford County Old
Settlers' reunion in Metamora, made a day of double interest, because of
the gathering of many notable and interesting personages of an older day,
that virtually formed a connecting link with the days when Abraham Lincoln
trod over the same ground upon which the thousands were gathered, with the
present era of automobiles and airplanes. Gray-haired people reflecting
over the past could not but note the wide variance between the horseback
and market-wagon days of sixty years ago and the auto lined streets, while
aloft an airplane flitted about.
Great Day's Program
The day's program was quite in
keeping with the spirit and importance of the occasion. Judge Gillespie,
in his address, slated that he considered the occasion sacred, and those
who listened to the addresses of Ex-Governor Fifer, Judge Gillespie, W. L.
Ellwood, James Piper, Prof. B. J. Radford and President Irving were so
impressed. There was an air of dignity about it all that was not lost
sight of in the pleasantries, the amusements and sports incident to a
celebration. Everything was clean, orderly and enjoyable, and satisfaction
was expressed and reflected on every hand.
The program was carried
out to the letter, with the exception of the absence of Senator Simon K.
Lantz, deputed to receive the deed to the old court house. Ex-Governor
Fifer acted in his stead, receiving the deed from Mayor J. C. Snyder, and
acknowledging its receipt on behalf of the State.
President J. C.
Irving presided throughout the program, calling the assembly to order at
10:30 in the morning, after a short concert by Elgin's band of Peoria.
Rev. J. D. Calhoun of "Washington gave the invocation and Dr. J. I.
Knoblauch, on behalf of Metamora, gave the address of welcome. Dr.
Knoblauch made a plea for an increase in membership in the Old Settlers'
association, which resulted in many new names being added to the roster.
Attorney W. L. Ellwood of Peoria responded to the address, on behalf of
the Old Settlers.
J. C. Irving Re-Elected.
J. C. Irving was
re-elected president of the Old Settlers' association, at the business
session held. Miss Lillian Theena was elected secretary. Resolutions upon
the death of members during the year past were adopted.
noon hour the park was a great picnic ground, many of the visitors having
brought picnic baskets. Hot coffee was served free at a stand in the
An airplane flight preceded the afternoon program and Elgin's
band gave a concert until 2 o'clock, when Governor Fifer delivered his
dedicatory address, a masterful effort, which appears in part in this
issue. At its close Mayor Snyder tendered the Ex-Governor the deed to the
old court house property, to forever remain the property of the
Judge Frank Gillespie of Bloomington delivered a beautiful
address immediately following the delivery of the deed.
Prof. B. J.
Radford of Eureka, who claimed the prize as the oldest native son of
Woodford county, having been born here in 1838, spoke reminiscently. He
related that in the old court house building he had heard Abraham Lincoln,
Judge Logan, David Davis and Bob Ingersoll speak. He sat on the wheel of
the wagon from which Lincoln spoke in Metamora in 1858, and in Galesburg
he stood for three hours during the delivery of the debate speeches of
Lincoln and Douglas. His father served on a jury in a case in which
Lincoln appeared as counsel and he remembers his father telling his mother
that he sat up until 2 o'clock in the morning listening to Lincoln telling
The contests and sports took place immediately at the
close of the oratorical program, and included various races for
Benson was the winner of the baseball game of the
after-noon, trimming Roanoke 16 to 3, in what proved to be an
uninteresting game. Ehresman was on the mound for Ben-son and had the game
in hand all through. Breyne, the Roanoke twirler, was batted all over the
lot, and to make matters worse his field support failed him
The morning game of baseball between the Washington
Liberties and Metamora was won by Metamora, 16-2.
The game of
horseshoes between Dewitt and Woodford counties was won by Dewitt
county. The purse was $50.
The day's program wound up with a
free moving picture show in the park, a concert by Elgin's band and a
pavement dance, the music being furnished by Dusey's orchestra of Peoria.
Fully 2,500 people saw the picture show and the dancers numbered nearly
The crowds in mid-afternoon were probably as large as
have ever been seen in Metamora. The estimated attendance by different
judges ran all the way from 6,000 to 10,000. It was an orderly crowd and
while tehre were plenty of police on hand, their principal duties were in
directing traffice and furnishing information.
Great credit is due
the business people of Metamora, all of whom contributed generously, as
did also a number of interested citizens, some of them from quite a
distance. Particular credit is due President J. C. Irving for his part in
arranging the program and his skillful handling of the same, and to the
executive committee, E. W. Knoblauch, J. W. Miller, F. W. Wagner, Wm. Noe,
E. V. Giehl and Wm. Ryan.
Address of W. L. Ellwood.
It is with much pleasure,
Dr. Knoblauch, that on behalf of the Old Settlers present I respond to
your cordial welcome extended us by the citizens of Metamora.
know better than I of the enterprise, hospitality and goodfellowship which
your citizens always show when the Old Settlers gather here, for I have
missed very few of their meetings held here during the last twenty-five
years. I know that no community in the State has a greater appreciation of
the importance and value of these gatherings, or does more to contribute
to the comfort and pleasure of its guests than the citizens of this
beautiful little village.
It is with me, sir, doubly pleasant to
have the privilege of speaking at this time in reply to your address of
Metamora will ever be near and dear to my heart. I
have been intimately acquainted with it and its older citizens for over 50
years. In 1865 my mother, a widow of the Civil War, moved to this town
from a farm near the village of Mackinaw.
Here my sister and myself
grew to adult age. With the exception of six months spent in Watseka,
where I first opened a law office, Metamora was my home from 1865 to
November, 1896. Here I studied law and practiced my profession
for more than 20 years. Here I have experienced success and sore defeat,
happiness and sorrow. Here my children were born, and their mother, and my
mother and my maternal grandparents, and other relatives, lie at rest in
your beautiful cemetery of Oakwood. I was intimately acquainted with your
citizens of 50 years ago, and know that the early settlers of this town
were an enterprising and intelligent people and representative of the
better class of Americans. Among them were the Pages, the Perrys, the
Whitmires, the Cassells, the Bantas and Rays, Babcock, Rockwell, Keeder
and Kellogg, Shope, Cross, Irving, dish, Chitty, Clark, Plank, Stevenson,
Lamson, Hartley, Kipp, Conrad, Rohman, and many others.
50 years ago Metamora had a good public library where the standard works
of history and biography, and the best works of fiction and miscellaneous
literature could be found. For many years, perhaps over 35, there was a
society here known as the Independent Order of Good Fellows. This was a
debating society, formed during the "War of the Rebellion, and it met once
a week and debated all kinds of questions. It was entertaining and
instructive, and many men who have since achieved success and distinction,
made their first speech in the Good Fellows' hall.
much of which to be proud. It is one of the most beautifully located
villages in Illinois, surrounded by a country extremely beautiful and
fertile, occupied by an industrious, intelligent and patriotic
Few communities of its size have had more men who have
left them to become distinguished in the business and political world,
than this. Simeon P. Shope became a leading lawyer of Fulton county, and
one of the Judges of the Supreme Court of Illinois. Adlai E. Stevenson
became a member of Congress, First Assistant Postmaster General, and
Vice-President of the United States. John L. Ray became one of the leading
lawyers of Champaign county and for many years stood at the head of its
bar. Andrew Banta became a prominent lawyer, and a member of the
Legislature in Kansas. Samuel S. Page became a Circuit Judge of this
District after he moved to Peoria, and later became one of the most
successful and brilliant trial lawyers of Chicago. His brother, George T.
Page, became one of the leading lawyers of Peoria, and is now a Judge of
the United States circiut Court at Chicago, which office he holds for
life. Dick Hartley, born here, is the State's Attorney at Salt Lake City,
I can not express the pleasure I feel in knowing that today
the State of Illinois is to receive a deed for the old Court House across
the way, and is to take over its care and upkeep.
That old building
is historic. Built in 1843, it has been the scene of many hotly contested
trials. Its courts have been presided over by an able and distinguished
line of judges. Among them have been Samuel H. Treat, afterwards a judge
of the United States Court. David Davis, after-wards United States
Senator, and a member of the Supreme Court of the United States, Mark
Bangs, Richmond, Burns, Shaw, McCulloch, Laws, Green, S. S. Page and
Nicholas E. Worthington.
Its walls have echoed to the eloquence of
Abraham Lincoln, Leonard Swett, George O. Barnes, John Burns, N. E.
Worthington, Adlai E. Stevenson, W. W. O'Brien and that prince of orators,
Robert G. Ingersoll.
I hope that your citizens will ever take an
interest in that old building. To the young men and women of this
community and county I would say, take an interest in your community and
county, and acquire a knowledge of the history of your county and of the
men who preceded you, for in the lives of the men who have gone before and
have developed and improved this section of our beautiful land there is
much to inspire and emulate.
Governor Fifer's Address.
In a little speech a year
ago at this place, I suggested that the old Court House be taken over by
the State. The suggestion seemed to make a favorable impression upon the
good people of this County, and through their efforts, and the efforts of
their representatives in the General Assembly, a bill to that end became a
law at the last session, and the Court House is now the property of the
State. I congratulate the people of Woodford County, and the people of the
whole state, upon the fact that the only remaining Court House of the old
Eighth Circuit is to be cared for and preserved by all the people.
The value of this modest temple of justice is not in its splendid
architecture, nor in the materials of which it is built, but rather in the
sacred memories that cluster about it. In this regard it is doubtful if a
more important or valuable court house can be found in the United States.
There were times when Abraham Lincoln, Adlai E. Stevenson, Robert G.
Ingersoll and Judge David Davis all met under the roof of that building,
not only once, but many times. No one would have believed at that time
that within the walls of that un-pretentious structure there were
assembled a future President and Vice-President, a future Judge of the
highest Judicial Body in the world, and the Greatest orator of his age,
and yet this all proved to be true.
The old Eighth Circuit, as it
is now called in history, embraced substantially the same territory that
is now ineluded in the Third Supreme Judicial District. Judge Davis was
the Judge of the Circuit, and nearly all of the leading lawyers of the
Circuit followed him from court to court, and I have been told they went
from county to county in the following order: From Sangamon to Tazewell,
then to Woodford, McLean, Logan, DeWitt, Ford, Piatt, Champaign,
Vermilion, Edgar, Coles, Shelby, Moultrie, Douglas and thence back to
It was in riding the Circuit that Lincoln became
acquainted with the great lawyers of Central Illinois, and laid the
foundation of that success which placed him in the Presidential chair, and
gave him a fame greater than that of any man of his time.
here in this County, in the midst of this people, that Adlai E. Stevenson,
who was one of the ablest and most discreet statesmen of his time, laid
the foundations of his future success.
It is equally true that
Judge David Davis is much indebted to the influence of the bar and the
people of the old Eighth Circuit for a career which placed him on the
Supreme Bench of the United States, and gave to him a reputation as one of
the greatest Judges of that august body.
So it will be seen when
all these facts are considered, that I have not over-stated the case when
I say that the building which we dedicate today is the most important and
the most memorable structure of the kind to be found in the United States.
It is to be hoped that the Governor of the State will appoint some worthy
custodian to have charge of it, and to see to it well that it is preserved
in all respects as we see it today.
I know of no one better qualified
for the position of custodian than Mr. J. C. Irving of this city, whose
father, I am told, erected the building many years ago.
memorial is now the property of the State, to be cared for by the state,
yet, my fellow citizens, it must always remain in your special keeping; in
the keeping of Woodford County.
It is well known that the Daughters
of the American Revolution are marking the trail of those who rode the old
Eighth Circuit, and when that work is completed, I am sure that the point
of greatest interest will be found right here in your beautiful little
city of Metamora.
My fellow citizens, you will note that great men
never come singly, but in groups. The Revolutionary War gave to the world
many great names. Washington, Hamilton, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, Adams,
and many others. It can clearly be seen that a successful revolution, and
the establishment of free institution in a wilderness, was destined to
send some names to the pantheon of fame, and so it was. Jackson was the
last Revolutionary President, and from his time down to the inauguration
of Abraham Lincoln, the Presidential chair was filled with
mediocrity. The event of the Civil War gave birth to another
group of great names, and among them the name of Abraham Lincoln, that
strange man who came among us, strode across this little grain of sand of
ours, and disappeared leaving the world in wonder and amazement at his
It is not only true that great men come in
groups, but it is true also that the event and the man must come together,
if one's greatness is to be known by the world, and it is equally true
that no man can be truly great unless he attaches his name to some great
movement for the benefit of mankind. All these conditions united to make
Abraham Lincoln the greatest character of his age. It is doubtful whether
Abraham Lincoln would have been known to the world, had it not been for
his great rival and contemporary, Stephen A. Douglas. The names of Lincoln
and Douglas will be forever associated together, and these two men are now
justly regarded as the greatest statesmen this country has produced since
the era of American Independence.
Friends, let us all emulate the
example of the great men who once assembled in yonder building. Let us
guard with the most scrupulous fidelity, even to the sacrifice of life
itself, the political institutions which have been handed down to us by
the august hands of our Revolutionary Fathers.
Attorney Gillespie's Address.
said in part: "And Abram said unto Lot, let there be no strife, I pray
thee, between me and thee, and between mv herdmen and thy herdmen; for we
be brethren. Is not the whole land before thee? Separate thyself, I pray
thee, from me: If thou wilt take the left hand, then I will go to the
right: or if thou depart to the right hand, then I will go to the
Pioneering is a law of life-a vital principle of life.
"Without the pioneer civilization would die. The fact that we have old
settlers pre-supposes the pioneer, the new settler of long ago.
is of the pioneer who in his evolutin has produced the old settler, I
speak today, and in speaking of them I say:
"Not as white saints
without a blot. We celebrate the deeds they wrought. For they were made of
average clay, as mortal men are made today. For always in dark hours of
need, a man is furnished for the deed. And always when the storm clouds
lowere, strong men are ready for the hour. And thus from earth's most
commone breed, spring heroes fit for every need."
Just common men
have kept the world and civilization going. They have the dynamic power of
body and soul. They, and they alone, have the power of movement, of
locomotion, and it is they who have gone out and pioneered. The sons of
Abraham were the sons of Hagar, an Egyptian hand maid. The world is
peopled with men of the royal blood of common men.
"If thou wilt
take the left hand, then I will go to the right; or if thou depart to the
right hand, then I will go to the left." This is the language of Abraham
to Lot, and Lot became the pioneer, for he went out into the plain, and
Abraham dwelt in the land of Canaan.
The pioneer, the old settler,
had to give up something. To be successful he must always forget self in
the grosser sense. His prayer must ever be: "Lord help me live from day to
day, in such a self-forgetful way, that even when I kneel to pray, my
prayer shall be for others. Help me in all the work I do to ever be
sincere and true, and know that all I'd do for you must needs be done for
others. Let self be crucified and slain and buried deep; and all in vain
may efforts be to rise again, unless to live for others. And when my work
on earth is done, and my new work in heaven's begun, may I forget the
crown I've won while thinking still of others. Others, Lord, yes others;
let this my motto be; help me to live for others, that I may live like
And so our fathers gave up established civilization, and
took up their abode in the wilderness. They gave up everything, that they
might achieve, that they might become cultured in liberty and freedom, and
they built this Republic wisely and well. And they built Illinois. I love
the waving fields of grain, the dawning skies of gold and sun, the
twilight hours when day is done; it's all in Illinois! Here lie the green
graves of our sires, of men who fought the country's wars, the loved and
lost of passing years, in Illinois, my