• Antioch Church of Christ, Roads (pre-1890)
• Assembly of God, Carrollton (1931) - Carrollton Twp
• Austin Chapel Methodist Episcopal (1860s) - Trotter Twp
• Battsville Church of Christ (1890's) submitted by Jerry Stephens
• Bethel Baptist Church
• Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church (1860) - Fairfield Twp
• Bethlehem Christian Church, Miami Station
• Bethlehem Baptist Church, Standish (1857)
• Big Creek Baptist Church, Bosworth (1844); Also called Big Creek Chapel - Ridge Twp
• Big Creek Methodist Episcopal, South Church (1851) - Van Horn Twp Section 2
• Bogard Church of Christ, Bogard (1949)
• Bogard Methodist Episcopal Church, Bogard (1884)
• Bosworth Baptist Church, Bosworth (1888)
• Bosworth Methodist Episcopal Church, Bosworth (1870s)
• Bower's Chapel Methodist Episcopal Church, Plymouth (1869); merged with Plymouth M.E. Church in 1873
• Bridge Creek Methodist Episcopal Church (1875); became Tina M.E. Church - Hurricane Twp
• Carrollton African Methodist Episcopal Church, Carrollton (1870s)-Carrollton Twp
• Carrollton Church of Christ, Carrollton (1911) - Carrollton Twp
• Central Christian Church, Bosworth (1901)
• Chapel Hill Church
• Christian Church, Miami Station (1890)
• Christian Science Church, Carrollton (1914) - Carrollton Twp
• Church of God (1873) - Rockford Twp, Section 8
• Church of God in Christ, Carrollton (1955) - Carrollton Twp
• Collier's Chapel Methodist Church (1911) - Sugar Tree Twp
• Coloma Baptist Church, Coloma (1867)
• Coloma Church of Christ, Coloma (1894)
• Coloma Presbyterian Church, Coloma (1870)
• Compton Methodist Episcopal Church (1861) - Compton Twp
• Cooper's Chapel Church of Christ (1898); Burned in 1918 - Trotter Twp
• DeWitt Baptist Church, DeWitt (1846) - DeWitt Twp
• DeWitt Christian Church, DeWitt (1869) - DeWitt Twp
• DeWitt Methodist Episcopal South Church, DeWitt (1875) - DeWitt Twp
• Emmanuel Lutheran Church, Carrollton (1870s) - Carrollton Twp
• Ebenezer Methodist Church (1865) - Leslie Twp
• Elizabeth Methodist Church, Elizabeth (1877)
• Enoch Church, Plymouth
• Enon Baptist Church (1881) - Hill Twp
• First Baptist Church, Bogard; began as The Mount Zion Church (1867)
• First Baptist Church, Carrollton (27 Aug 1839) - Carrollton Twp
• First Christian Church, Carrollton (1845) - Carrollton Twp
• First Christian Church, Hale (1898)
• First Church of the Nazarene, Carrollton (1958) - Carrollton Twp
• First Presbyterian Church, Carrollton (1866) - Carrollton Twp
• First United Methodist Church, Carrollton; began as Methodist Episcopal South (1840) -  Carrollton Twp
• First United Methodist Church, DeWitt (1875) - DeWitt Twp
• Free Gospel Assembly of God, Bosworth (1951)
• Gibbs Chapel Methodist Church (1893) - Hill Twp (10 miles due west of Hale)
• Gilead Missionary Baptist Church (1867); began as Moss Creek Church - Carrollton Twp
• Grace Methodist Episcopal Church (1880s) - five miles west of Hale
• Hale Baptist Church, Hale (1884)
• Hale Church of Christ, Hale (1884)
• Hale Methodist Episcopal Church, Hale (1861)
• Hazel Dell Latter Day Saints (1873) - Washington Twp
• Hurricane Baptist Church (1868) - Compton Twp
• Liberty Methodist Church (1879) - 6 miles NE of Carrollton
• Little Flock Regular Baptists Church (1845) - Leslie Twp
• Little Ridge Baptist Church
• Low Gap Baptist Church, Plymouth (1876)
• Mandeville Christian Church, Mandeville (1846)
• Mandeville Church of Christ, Mandeville (1844)
• Mandeville Methodist Episcopal Church, Mandeville (1868)
• McBee Chapel United Methodist Church, Braymer (pre-1888)
• McCroskie Creek Baptist Church (1855) (commonly known as Beaty Church) -  Trotter Twp
• McGill's Creek Missionary Baptist Church (1871) - Trotter Twp Section 26
• Memorial Methodist Church, Carrollton - Carrollton Twp
• Methodist Episcopal Church - Trotter Twp (1870)
• Moss Creek Methodist Episcopal South Church (1853) - Moss Creek Twp
• Moss Creek Missionary Baptist Church (1967); became Gilead Missionary Baptist and moved to Carrollton Twp
• Mount Carmel Christian Church, Roads (1880s)
• Mount Carmel Methodist Episcopal Church (1880) - Combs Twp
• Mount Olive Baptist Church, Roads (1860s)
• Mount Olive Wesleyan Methodist Episcopal Church (1860s)
• Mount Olivet Methodist Episcopal South Church (1879); with Burying Grounds of 2 acres - Prairie Twp Section 6
• Mount Tabor United Brethren Church, Plymouth (1872 -1954)
• Mount Zion Baptist Church (1863) - Carrollton Twp
• Neal Chapel - Sugar Tree Twp
• New Salem Baptist Church (1894); burned down abt 1998 - NW of Coloma
• Norborne Baptist Church, Norborne (1870)
• Norborne African Methodist Episcopal Church, Norborne (1915)
• Norborne Christian Church, Norborne (1871)
• Norborne Methodist Episcopal South Church, Norborne (1869)
• Norborne Missionary Baptist Church, Norborne (1870)
• North Miami Baptist Church (1894)
• Oakland Christian Church, Tina (1874)
• Open Bible Christian Church (1961); Moved to Carroll County in 1963
• Pleasant Hill Christian Church, Standish (1879)
• Pleasant Hope Methodist Episcopal Church (1865) - Trotter Twp
• Pleasant Park Methodist Episcopal Church, Miami Station (1837)
• Plymouth Methodist Episcopal Church, Plymouth (1865); merged with Bower's Chapel M.E. Church in 1873
• Providence Church (1868)
• River View Church (1901)
• Rock Branch Southern Methodist Church, Rock Branch; Officially St. Mary's Chapel S.M. Church (pre-1898 to 1927)
• Rock Hill Church of Christ (pre-1890) - Trotter Twp
• Rockford Church of Christ, Bosworth
• Rush Chapel Methodist Episcopal Church, Coloma (1858)
• Sacred Heart Catholic Church, Norborne (1878)
• Saint Bernard Roman Catholic Church (circa 1850)
• Second Baptist Church, DeWitt (abt 1868)
• Shady Grove Presbyterian Church, Shady Grove; merged with Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian in 1933
• Snow Branch Dunkard Church (1871) - Ridge Twp Section 36
• Southside Baptist Church, Carrollton (1953) - Carrollton Twp
• St. Mary's Catholic Church, Carrollton (1868) - Carrollton Twp
• St. Paul's Episcopal Church, Carrollton (1872) - Carrollton Twp
• Taylor's Chapel Church of Christ (1885) - Trotter Twp
• Thompson Chapel Methodist Episcopal Church (1845); began as Moss Creek Methodist Episcopal Church - Moss Creek Twp
• Tina Baptist Church, Tina (1903)
• Tina Christian Church, Tina (1887)
• Tina Methodist Episcopal Church, Tina; originally the Bridge Creek Methodist Episcopal Church
• Trinity Lutheran Church, Norborne (1869)
• Trotter Baptist Church, Trotter (1871)
• Union Baptist Church (1867) - Roads
• Union United Brethren (1867) - Fairfield Twp
• United Church of Tina (1961); merger of the Methodist and Christian Churches
• Utica Baptist Church
• Van Horn Methodist Episcopal Church, Standish (1884)
• Virginia Street Baptist Church (1863)
• Wakenda Methodist Church (submitted by Jerry Stephens) 
• Wakenda Missionary Baptist Church (1844) - Eastern Carrollton Twp
• Wakenda Church of Christ (1916)
• Walnut Grove Baptist Church (1868)
• Welch Calvinistic Methodist Church (1872) - Washington Twp Section 3
• Welch Congregational Church (1880) -Washington Twp Section 17 NE Corner
• Woolsey's Grove Baptist Church, Bowdry (1872)

If I have missed any churchs in Carroll County please let me know so that I may include them.  Also if someone has a picture of one of the older established churchs they would like to share please send it to me, so I can include it on this page.

Wakenda Baptist Church picture submitted by Don Winfrey