A part of Ohio Trails for Genealogy Trails

Allen County, Ohio

John Dillinger

On August 14, 1933 Harry Copeland, Hilton Crouch and John Dillinger robbed The Citizens National Bank of Bluffton. Taken in the robbery was a revolver and $2,100. A few weeks later, John Dillinger was arrested for the robbery at his girlfriend's home in Dayton, Ohio. He was extradited to the Allen County jail on September 27th to await trial.

The day before his extradition, Dillinger's gang members escaped from the Indiana Prison in Michigan City. Among the escapees were Harry Pierpont, John Hamilton, Charles Makley and Russell Clark. The gang hid out on a farm owned by Pierpont's parents near Leipsic, Ohio. On October 3, 1933 they robbed the First National Bank of St. Marys in hopes of getting enough money to finance the escape of John Dillinger.

On October 12, 1933, at 6:30 PM, Harry Pierpont, Charles Makley, and Russell Clark entered the office of Sheriff Jesse Sarber at the Allen County Jail. Sheriff Sarber was seated at his desk reading. His wife sat near him working a crossword puzzle. Deputy Wilbur Sharp, who was not in uniform, sat on a nearby couch.

The three men told Sarber that they were from the prison in Michigan City, IN and wanted to question Dillinger. When Sarber requested identification, Pierpont replied, "Here is our credentials," and pulled his revolver. When Jesse Sarber reached for his gun in the desk, Pierpont fired one round into the sheriff's stomach severing a major artery. When Sarber attempted to stand up, Makley pistol-whipped him about the head.

The three demanded the keys to the cell and struck the dying sheriff again stopping only after Mrs. Sarber cried, "Let Dad alone! I'll get the key!" Mrs. Sarber and Deputy Sharp were pushed into the cell as Dillinger picked up his jacket and walked out. 

Mrs. Sarber and Deputy Sharp broke out a window in the cell and began yelling for help. After help arrived, the sheriff was taken to the hospital about 7 PM but died at 8:05. He was 47 years old.

The Dillinger gang was apprehended in January of 1934 in Tucson, Arizona. Pierpont, Makley and Clark were charged with the killing of Sheriff Jesse Sarber and were brought back to the Allen County Jail to await their trials. Dillinger was extradited to Crown Point, Indiana to await trial for the killing of a Chicago policeman.

During the trials, security was tight around the Allen County Courthouse complex. The jail was surrounded by barbed wire; machine-gun nests were set up behind sandbagged barricades and on nearby rooftops. Eight-foot fences guarded the sheriff's residence. National Guardsmen patrolled the grounds and machine-guns were placed at the ends of the jail corridors. Complicating the situation, Dillinger escaped his Indiana captors by using a carved wooden gun. In spite of threats to free his friends, Dillinger never made it to Lima, Ohio.

Harry Pierpont was sentenced to death on March 11, 1934 followed by Charles Makley on March 17th. Russell Clark was sentenced to life imprisonment. In an attempted escape in September of 1934, Makley was shot and killed by Ohio Penitentiary guards and Pierpont was wounded. Pierpont was executed by the state on October 17, 1934. Russell Clark served time until 1968 when it was discovered that he was dying of cancer. He was released on August 14th, 35 years to the day after the Bluffton bank robbery. He died on Christmas Eve, 1968.

John Dillinger, who became Public Enemy Number One on the FBI's most wanted list following the murder of Sheriff Jesse Sarber, was shot and killed in an ambush outside of the Biograph Theater in Chicago on July 22, 1934. Dillinger and Sarber were both born on June 28th--18 years apart.

Submitted by: Norita Moss

Click Here to Return to Allen County, Ohio

Click Here to Return to Ohio Trails

Click Here to Return to Genealogy Trails

Hosted by Linda Dietz
Created for Genealogy Trails History Project 2007
All Rights Reserved©