Babb's Switch School House Fire

The torment and hurt of one couple whose little girl, Mary Elizabeth Edens, who was never found amid the ashes of the school house building remains, could only assume that their little girl had been completely destroyed in this devastating fire.  They were not able of closure in laying the remains to rest.  Many years passed, but little Mary Elizabeth was never forgotten by her parents and siblings.  The little girls aunt who died two days after the fire, managed to tell the Edens that she had handed her daughter unhurt to someone outside before she collapsed.  Little did they know what awaited them more than thirty years after the day of devastationIn the early part of 1957 the lost was found.  Mrs. Grace Reynolds of Barstow, California was discovered to be the little Mary Elizabeth Edens.  Apparently, during the activity of the fire when a couple was  handed little Mary Elizabeth outside the building  this couple was not from the area, and they took the little girl with them probably believing the parents had died in the fire.  Reports of investigartors had found they had went first to Arkansas, then to Kansas, and then finally abandoned her in California.  The little girl was left on her own.    At the age of about 15 she was adopted.  She later married and started a family, never knowing anything about her parents or other relatives.  The following is articles that were in The Oklahoman, this is just a small portion of them that were printed.

LONG-LOST 'VICTIM' SEES BABBS SWITCH
The Oklahoman, Feb. 10, 1957 Page 128

Saturday was a day of rejoicing in Hobart as the long-lost victim of the tragic Babbs Switch school fire and her family began bridging the gap left by the last 32 years.  The jubilant L. F. Edends family spent the day greeting a steady stream of visitors to their home and answering calls from hundreds of curious Hobart friends anxious to meet their daughter and confirm first hand reports that the missing person had been found.
The fire victim, Mrs. Grace Reynolds, now a prominent 36-year-old Barstow, California business woman alternately smiled and cried as she met her parent's friends and relatives.
Saturday afternoon she visited the farm where her parents lived at the time she disappeared, inspected the old Babbs Switch school site near Hobart and stood crying at the cemetery where the 36 persons who died in the fire are buried.
The Edens family meanwhile made telephone calls to relatives in all sections of the country to report the discovery of their daughter.
They're all coming here, Mrs. Edens told newsmen Saturday afternoon.  They will start arriving here tomorrow (Sunday).  You just can't realize how happy we are now.  Words just cannot describe our joy.
The Edens couple was present at a school program on Christmas eve 1924 at the Babbs Switch school when a fire broke out.  A panic developed in the tiny one-room school house.  Thirty six persons were killed, about 80 injured, including the Edens couple.
All of the victims in the fire were accounted for except the Edens 3 1/2 years old daughter, Mary Elizabeth.  No trace of her could be found in the ashes of the school house.  In the confusion the night of the fire no one had remembered seeing her.
An aunt had been holding the child when the fire broke out.  She managed to stagger outside, and died two days later.  But she made a death bed statement saying she had managed to get Mary Elizabeth out and thrust her into the arms of someone standing outside the school building.  The aunt had managed to keep the child from being burned.
A long, seemingly hopeless search followed.  But the Edens never gave up the belief that their daughter was alive somewhere.  They had concluded some childless couple had taken the child, thinking its parents were dea.
A newspaper story last autumn was read by friends of Mrs. Reynolds in Barstow.  An investigation was begun and evidence discovered which convined the Edens coupe and Mrs. Reynolds that she was the missing Babb's Switch fire victim.
Mrs. Reynolds flew to Oklahoma City to meet the Edens couple and their two married daughters, Mrs. Betty Reynolds of Hobart and Mrs. Wilburn Henderson of 4308 NW 13 in Oklahoma City. 
Mrs. Reynolds said she recalls being taken to California where she was abandoned, later worked for room and board and was finally adopted by a San Diego woman when she was 15.
I gave myself a name, she said.  I even picked my own birthday.  (She picked her age at three years older than she really is).  I remember having all sorts of trouble trying to get a birth certificate, and trying to find out something about my background, she said.
There is no question in my mind now but that the Edens are my real parents, she told newsmen.
Mrs. Reynolds said she plans to spend at least a week with her parents in Hobart and then return to Barstow.
We're trying to get her to move back to Oklahoma, Mrs. Edens told newsmen Saturday afternoon.  We need her out here.  There is so much time we have to make up.
Mrs. Reynolds is divorced now and has a 12 year old son, Louis, and a 2 month old adopted son, Leon.
A photograph of the son strongly resembles a son of Mrs. Betty Reynolds of Hobart who is almost the same age.
The discovery of the Edens daughter was the principal topic of conversation in Hobart Saturday.  Many of the city's residents witnessed the fire and many still bear scars from it.  Most were intimately acquainted with the mystery of the missing Edens child.
The Edens family had kept is investigations and coorespondence with Mrs. Reynolds in California a secret until their reunion in Oklahoma City Friday afternoon.  Relatives explained they didn't want to make any mistakes in identification or encourage hopes that she had been found until they were positive themselves.  Her 12 year old son has the same name as her father, Louis Ebens.


Hobart Writes Happy Ending

Joyous Reunion of Edens Family Blots Out 32 Years of Sorrow



The Oklahoman Feb. 24, 1957 Page 80 written by Clara Neal
Hobart--Ten days is not nearly long enough to catch up on 32 missing years--so a Hobart family, reunited with their daughter who disappeared at the time of the Babbs Christmas Eve fire in 1924, will get together again next June.  When Mrs. Grace Reynolds, the long missing daughter of Mr. and Mrs. L. F. Edens, retired Hobart farm couple, left this week for her home in Barstow, California.  It was with plans to return for the full month of June, bringing along her two children.

Already answered are many questions as to events in the life of 3 1/2 yar old Mary Elizabeth Edens after she disappeared that bitter cold Christmas Eve night when 36 persons died in the country schoolhouse fire which shocked the nation.  Eventually the family hopes to know the rest of the story--what actually happened that night.

The stranger-than-fiction story, which came to lifhgt February 8, when Mrs. Reynolds arrived in Oklahoma City by plane to meet the Edens family, has fallen into place in much the same manner as a jigsaw puzzle.  Everything fits.

Not only is there the identifiying scar on her right foot which was final proof so far as the family was concerned, but there has been one long string of continuing conincidences.  She and her two sisters, Mrs. Wilburn Henderson, Oklahoma City and Mrs. Herb Reynolds, Hobart, are the same height, five feet and threeinches.  They were the same size dresses, the same size shoes, gloves and rings. 

There are strong family resemblances in appearance, voices and handwriting.  She and her Hobart sister not only have the same married names but each has a son named Louis--which, incidentally is their father's name.  Actually the California Mrs. Reynolds has two sons with the name.  Her oldest son, 12 years old, is Louis Leon.  The youngest, and adopted child two months old, is Leon Louis.  As to why she named her children Louis, she explains--It always was a favorite name of mine.

She herself, has no recollection of the fire.  Her earliest memories are of a woman she knew as her mother.  She plans to talk with her in the hope of learning more about her early life.  She declined to release her name to newspaper reporters.  She remembers when her "mother" married.  I must have been six or seven years old then, the best I can figure, she said.  Soon after that, I was given to another woman and lived with her, helping do house work.  They were living in Kansas then.  After that, she recalls a succession of homes in which she lived, but periodically going back to her "mother" and her husband.

Always, I can remember, I'd push away from my mother when she showed signs of affection.  I felt inside that she was not my mother, she said.  She started to school in Helena, Kansas but her education was sporadic, adding up altogether to only six years formal schooling. 

She remembers being taken to Arkansas when she was still a young girl.  She lived with a family there, helping take care of their children for a year and a half.  Then her mother who still was in Kansas wrote that they were going to Californiz and wanted to know if she would like to go along.  She deided to go.  I must have been about 14 years old then, She said.  Arriving in California, she started to school in Los Angeles but that lasted only a short time.  She went to work for a Jewish family in North Hollywood.  They wanted a full time girl, so I had to quit school again.  I was making all of $15 a month when I was 14 years old she recalled.

Her next move took her to San Diego where she lived with Mrs. Mae Laforet, who later became her foster moteher.  She was legally adoptred by Mrs. Laforet when she was 16 years old, with her own consent.  Mrs. Laforet was one of the first to tell her how happy she was when the story of the reunion with her parents went out over the nation's wire services, television and radio.

During the war, most other people on the west coast, she turned to a defense plant for employment, working for the Standard Parachute factory in San Diego.  It was after the war that she first went to work for a dress shop--work which she liked and in which she made rapid advancement.  After her marriage, she moved to Bakersfield where she managed a store and worked in department stores, part of the time as a window decorator.

She now owns her own dress shop in Barstow, employing three clerks and a teenager.  The later, incidentally has won the title of Miss Barstow of 1957.  The Miss Barstow title is something of a contest for her teen age employes, having been won by them the last three years.

Mrs. Reynolds has lived in Barstow seven years working first in a restruant there and then selling insurance before putting in her dress shop four years ago.  Divorces from her husband, she maintains a home for herself and the two children.

"Oklahoma people" she saive have expressed interest in the adoption of my younges son.  In California, adoption does not require two parents.   The requirements are simply that the applicant be able to provide a good home and have a good moral background.

Somewhat weary, but happy, after 10 days of constant meeting people and answering telephone calls from all parts of the nation, Mrs. Reynolds was expecting more of the same when she gets home. "This has all come as a big surprise to people in Barstow," she said, "People there did not even know I had never known who my parents were."

It seems as a surprise to Hobart people, too.  Even though Mr. and Mrs. Edens had never given up, either people has believed that little Mary Elizabeth must have perished in the fire although no identifyable remains were ever found.  Very few people knew of the times, one of them only last Christmas that the Edens family had followed clues which they had hoped would lead them to their daughter--only to be disappointed.

To avoid further possible disappointment, the daughters did not tell their parents when Elmond H. Place, accountant, of San Bernardino and Barstow, contacted them December 31 after reading an Associated Press article about the missing Mary Elizabeth in the Sundan San Bernardino Times.  With offices in the same building with Mrs. Reynold's dress shop, he was one of the few persons who knew her background.  It was only a week before the reunion, and after the daughters were fairly certain that this was it at last they told their mother and father. 

Incredulous when the story broke, Hobart people looked forward to a  happy reunion enthusiastically to help the Enenses welcome their daughter. The reaction reflected the terrific impact made by the fire on the community. Flowers began to arrive, neighbors brought in food and people came in steady streams to the Edens home in Hobart's north residential district. There was laughter--and tears. As one of the daughters described it--"It's like a combination wedding, funeral, and birth."

Some 200 people attended a tea Friday afternoon in the First Baptist church basement. Others crowded around the family to greet them when they attended morning services in the Baptist church as a group last Sunday morning.

There were many gifts--a valentine box of candy from Hobart's chief of police Doss Kitch, and another heart-shaped candy box from her uncle Aaron Edens, Sterling, Colo., who explained that it "just happeneded" to have a red-headed doll on it. Mrs. Reynolds, who has red hair, said the doll is the first she ever remembers owning.

There was an ash try from the "western" collection of W. L. Parr who wanted her to have a "little bit of Oklahoma" to take back with her. He had usea a horse shoe and a cow's horn in making it.

One of the most prized gifts was a panel of pictures arranged by a local photographer at the time of the Babbs fire. Originally the property of the late W.W. Huff, it hung for years in the Snug Hotel here. It was a gift from Robert Huff, son of the original owner.

Among her visitors was G. W. Long, who had mad Mary Elizabeth's first picture at Christmas time in 1022, when she was six months old. Now retired, he lives at Lone Wolf.

Telephone calls continued to come from relatives and friends in many states, as well as from complete strangers, including several wanting to be their agent and others wanting to write a book. These latter have all received the same sanswer--"We're perfectly happy as we are, right now."

One thing she is having to get used to is a new birthday--and being two years older than she thought she was. She had thought she was 35 years old and her birthday was on July 11. Now it is June 22, her father's is June 26, and one of her sisters, Mrs. Henderson, has a June 28 birthday.

The birthdays are one reason they selected June for her trip back here. She plans to arrive June 1 and a family reunion is planned for June 21, at Quartz Mountain lodge. She already has met 11 uncles and aunts and "40 dozen" cousins and other relatives. All these, and more, too are expected back for the June reunion.


Eden Family Returns Home


Publication: The Oklahoman, April 7, 1957 Page 135
Hobart, April 6--Mr. and Mrs. L. F. Edens have returned from Barstow, California where they spent a bust week visiting their newly found daughter, Mrs. Grace Reynolds, her husband and two children.  Mrs. Edens said her daughter has been reconciled with her husband, Ray Reynolds.  During their stay in California, they appeared on Art Linkletter's "House Party" TV show.  There still is no further information, Mrs. Edens said, on what actually happened the night of the Babbs Christmas Eve fire in 1924 when their little daughter, Mary Elizabeth, disappeared, not to be found again until a few weeks ago.  She said they still are fully convinced Mrs. Reynolds is their daughter.  She and her family plan to come for an Edens family reunion in June.


Babb's Switch Fire 'Victim' Now a Bride

The Oklahoman, Nov 19, 1958 Page 23
Colorado Springs, Colo., Nov. 18--An Oklahoma woman who for 32 years was believed to have died in a schoolhouse fire is now a happy bride.  She is Mary Elizabeth Edens, 37, who was married to Arthur Strong of Lakewood, a Denber suburb.  The wedding was at the farm home of Mrs. Strong's uncle, Aaron Edens, 65 miles southeast of Colorado Springs.  The strange story of the woman's long disappearance began on Christmas Eve, 1924.  Residents of the Babbs Switch community, near Hobart, Oklahoma, gathered in the schoolhouse for a Christmas party.  A brightly decorated tree blazing with candles burst suddenly into flame.  A burning branch fell across several cans partly filled with gasoline.  An explosion hurled a great ball of fire through the schoolhouse.  When the fire at last was put out, 30 persons were reported dead.  But only 29 bodies were recovered.  Missing was Mary Elizabeth Edens, 3.  A relative said she thrust the girl into the arms of a man outside the schoolhouse.  But the girl could not be found.  Early in 1957 a Barstow, California, accountant happened to read a story about the Babb's Switch fire.  He talked about it with a woman he knew as Mary Reynolds, who owned a dress shop.  They became convinced she was really the missing Mary Elizabeth Edens.  On Feb. 8, 1957, she was re-united in Oklahoma City with her parents, who had survived the fire.  The Strongs plan to live in Lakewood where he operates a painting and decorating business.

 

BACK