THE OLD HOME WEEK BOOK
History of the Village of Prospect, PA
Transcribed and Donated by Robert A. Stumpf
Chapter V
Spellings And School Exhibitions
The old-time spellings and school exhibitions were occasions of much interest
and where properly conducted of great educational value. From an article
published in one of the county papers some time ago by our co-worker, we
quote: "Orthography, which includes the exact spelling of words, is an elementary
branch of an English Education, which, if defective, in a certain measure
vitiates the whole course of after study embraced in the curriculum of our
grammer and high schools."
"The first superintendent of public schools of Butler county, Isaac Black,
who has been sleeping for many a year in the cemetery of Bloomington, Neb.
--peace to the sleeper -- in 1854-7, was very rigid in his examination of
teachers in the matter of spelling. both orthographically and phonetically.
His strict requirement along the line of correct spelling creating a laudable
emulation among the pupils of the whole county, which bore fruitage in a
crop of excellent spellers of the day.
I remember a spelling contest that took place in ante bellum days, at the
close of a term of the Connoquenessing Academy, in the town of Zelienople.
The Rev.W.A. Passavant, D.D., of blessed memory, and of Orphans School fame,
offered a Webster's Unabridged Dictionary as a contest-prize to the best
speller. Three eminent physicians were the judges: Joseph Lusk, M.D., O.D.
Palmer, M.D., and Dr. Schmidt. It was an oral spelling match, and Prof. Josiah
R. Titzel, Principal of the Academy, pronounced the words. No second trial
was granted.
When the contestant mispelled a word, Mr. Titzel said, in a low tone of
voice,"missed", and the speller rose from his seat and walked to the rear,
or crestfallen left the hall. More than one hundred entered the contest.
All the words in Cobb's spelling-book were exhausted. Another spelling book
was handed to the pronouncer -- Townsend's, I think it was. The contestants
at last were reduced to two -- Albert Metz, afterward Dr. Metz, and myself.
The excitement was intense especially to Al and me. At last I missed the
first syllable of a word. The quiet Professor was quick to announce it, and
Metz won the dictionary.,BR>
Dr. Metz died many years ago at Sharpsburg, where he was practicing his
profession. Dr. Passavant, the Judges, Prof. Titzel and nine-tenths of the
contestants on that occasion have fallen asleep.
More than fifty years ago I had the honor and the pleasure of teaching the
Mile Run school, north of Prospect, and I had boys and girls in my classes
there who could spell every word in Osgood's spelling book. So thoroughly
did they prepare their spelling lessons that many times all the words in
the lesson were spelled by the uplifted hand method before the books were
opened for training in the Phonetic spelling of words.
Quoting from a letter: "The little, easy word that 'downed' me was
p-o-l-t-r-o-o-n. It was 'mixed in' with other dissyllables --'paltry','palfrey',
'palsey', etc., and automatically, I spelled the first syllable --'pal'
--immediately correcting it, before spelling the last syllable, but --it
was "too late" -- 'no second trial permitted' -- shut me out and I lost the
Dictionary. It was a sore disappointment to me, and one that I could not
get out of my mind for a long time after. I never 'missed' the word before
and I am sure that I shall never miss it again -- unless I lose my memory."
The little boy recalls a similar experience when, in the school in Prospect
he stood spelling against a dear school companion -- Clara Reed -- after
all the others were spelled down. The word he was caught on was an easy one
--"bodily" -- and he too -- through the automatic habit, put an "o" in the
middle where the "i" is, and lost the premiership of the occasion, to have
the proper spelling of the word so deeply impressed on his mind that he shall
never forget it, even if he lose his memory.
About once a week, commonly the last half day, a match was arranged in which
all the pupils were contestants. Two of the best spellers were appointed
captains and an understanding was arrived at as to which should have first
choice, and then they began to call out the names of the boys an girls they
chose, takng choice about, until all were chosen. As their names were called
the children ranged themselves in line on the side of their captain. And
then the teacher gave out the words and the spellers spelled, or missed spelling,
them correctly, and whoever missed had to sit down -- "spelled down", we
termed it; and so it went until all were down or the proud victor stood alone,
who had "spelled down the whole school".
But what is to be said about such a contest in thse days of so called "simplified
spelling? It could not be held. The crude spelling of Josh Billings and Artemas
Ward was a sort of cheap wit that made us children laugh in those days of
higher ideals of order and respect for authority. Now, every ignoramus who
knows not how to spell according to the rules by which the identity of words
in their respective root-meanings is preserved, spells to suit his taste,
and a fine mess he makes of it. He breaks the continuity of the chain by
which the language is held together, destroys the means by which the derivation
of words can be ascertained and their sense and exact shades of meaning
established, and by so doing not only darkens counsel by words without wisdom
but also destroys the history and the poetry bound up in the words themselves.
The building of language has its architectural style just as the building
of a house has. The words that come into the English language are derived
from nearly all the known languages of the civilized world, living and dead,
and they preserve in their correct forms, the marks and traces of the rock
whence they were hewn. But while an archeologist will recognize the beauty
and know something of the history and value of a pillar or tablet, transported
to a new locality and builded into a modern structure and becharmed and edified
by what he sees and knows, the untaught eye sees nothing and the untrained
mind receives no more enlightenment than from a comman stone. And it is quite
so that the arrogant advocates of the new way of spelling the words of the
English language are missing the precious associations of the words they
are trying to change. The movement began with half-educated scribblers, often
editors of little country newspapers, who never could spell correctly and
then covered up their ignorance by laughing at their errors.
At a house party one evening the young folk were playing some sort of game
in which each letter in a word was represented of some object brought into
the room, the name of which was to begin with the first letter of the object.
One girl had to bring in an article the name of which began with the letter
"c" -- and the girl brought in a saucer. That was in the days when correct
spelling, according to long, established and universally recognized rules,
was rated at a higher value than it is now. Who can describe the feelings
of her friends and the mortification of the poor girl when the situation
dawned upon them. She was so ashamed that she cried. She had at least the
saving grace of humility to save her ignorance from condemnation and had
the sympathy of the writer when others laughed at her, but the blatant advocates
of the so-called "improved spelling" of the present day exhibit no such emotion.
When their errors are pointed out to them they swell with indignation and
defend their mistakes by quoting Andrew Carnegie and Col. Roosevelt as authority
for their spelling.
Mr. Carnegie and Mr. Roosevelt are great in their respective fields. Mr.
Carnegie has control over much money and Mr. Roosevelt has great political
influence; but what right this gives either of them to meddle with the
foundations of the English language does not appear. It is as much mine as
it is theirs. They have no right above the right of any other individual
to tamper with the common property of the English-speaking world. It is
presumption gone mad to do or attempt such a thing. Who does it lays hands
on the inheritance of the whole people.
The dignity of the mother-tongue of millions is assailed and it is for the
interested millions to resent and check the attempted spoliation. The simplified
spellers have no more right to change the spelling of our words than they
have tto change the spelling of our names.
It will be observed that I spell my collaborator's name (with his approval),
McCulloch -- that means something, "a son of the lake"; the name is commonly
spelled with the final syllable "lough". What does that mean?
My mother's maiden name was Buechle, or in the original German Buchle, the
"u" with the umlaut, the nearest approach to which in English is "ue"; and
the name means a little book". It has been changed by many who bear it into
Beighley. What does that mean?
Stick to the right spelling just as firmly as to other things right, if you
can. Be thorough, not "thoro:. What does "thoro" mean? Thorough is allied
to through, the whole way. What does "thro" mean? Good night! Gud nite!
But there were school exhibitions at the close of the term usually, or sometimes
contests between rival schools, which were very entertaining to the pupils
and their friends, as well as the general public. One of the notable occasions
of this kind was a contest held in the little, old school-house in the times
of James B. Matthews. He was then teacher of a school which was located in
a building known as the "Steam school-house". It was somewhere in the Frazier
neighborhood between Portersville and Prospect. The meeting between the "Steam"
school and the Prospect school was in the winter and half a dozen or more
sleds, driven by James Frazier, Sr., some of the McClymonds, Wallaces and
others, came loaded with the pupils and their friends. The Townsend spelling
book was used. Mr. Matthews wore a blue suit, the coat of which buttoned
up to the neck and had several rows of large, bright buttons in front. He
ranged his largest boys, about a dozen of them -- and they were big fellows
-- in a line that reached nearly the length of the room, and then, standing
before them, pronounced the words, which they first spelled in concert and
then chanted the meaning of the word and its antithesis: as for example,"Helpful,
full of help, helpless, without help, artful, full of art, artless, without
art, needful, full of need, needless, without need, merciful, full of mercy,
merciless, without mercy;" and so forth for a long time, to the awe and amazement
of the little boy beside his sister in the audience. What other performances
they went through he does not remember, but they must have been nearly perfect,
for the boys said, afterward, that Mr. Matthews had a secret code which he
worked by touching certain buttons on his coat so that the school knew what
answers to give.
Mr. Matthews was an industrious but self-taught teacher of "ye olden time":.
He was ambitious in the Profession of Teaching and labored up until he became
the Principal of the Butler Schools and Superintendent of the common schools
of the county. He deserves credit for that for he did it against disadvantages
and without help from others. He never had the privilege of attending any
select school, academy, or institution of higher education. But he was merciless
in his use of the rod when he taught the Prospect school. He terrified every
one in the house at times, when he thrashed a fellow in earnest.
Another occasion which left its impress for life on the memory of the little
boy, was the "School Convention" held in the Lutheran church in the spring
of 1853 or 54, in which one of the schools taking part in the exercises was
the same "Steam School", from the Frazier district, taught by James B. Matthws.
Of it Mr. McCulloch writes: "I think that Isaac Black was teacher at Prospect
that term. Declamation was one of the principal contests between the schools.
Your brother George had printed for you in large letters:
"You'd scarce expect one of my age
To speak in public on the stage,
And if I chance to fall below
Demosthenes or Cicero,
Don't view me with a critics' eye
But pass my imperfections by."
"Great oaks from little acorns grow,
Great streams from little fountains flow." etc., etc.
You were a litte fellow and "brought down" the house with great hand-clapping
applause. Then came the "Steam School" turn and it put up on the stage a
little fellow, but about two sizes larger than you -- one, Milt McClymonds
-- now Professor in the State Normal School at Slippery Rock. He acquitted
himself with credit -- but when it was over all the Prospect boys shouted:
"Luther beat! Luther beat!
Speaking of this recalls the unique comment of a woman: "There", said she,
"There up come the little whiffet and spoke up just like a puppet!" and what
she meant is a mystery unto this day, but doubtless it was intended to be
something compimentary.
"Then later," quoting again, "we had an exhibition in the same church given
by Prof. McMillan school, 1854 or 55, when Warren, representing Parson Somebody,
(I have forgotten the name) delivered a lecture on Temperance, taking as
his subject the word M.A.L.T., with Jim Marshall, Aaron McGowan, Charley
Sullivan, your George, myself and a lot of other boys. Warren mounted a box
and we stood in a semi-circle around him. Ah Me! those were glorious days
to us boys. We always got the Lutheran church for our exhibitions. Your father
was so kind to the boys."
One more quotation, from the same authority, which has already been in print,
shall conclude the chapter: it is in the form of a letter to G.P. Weigle,
teacher of Whitestown school, who calls the writer of it, justly and
appropriately, "The Ridpath of Butler County." "Your report of the Whitestown
school brought to mind a term of school which I attended in that ancient
hamlet, in the summer of 1847. It was a subscription school and John B.Campbell
wielded the birch." His motto was, 'Spare the rod and spoil the child', and
he was a conscientious pedagogue -- as all teachers should be -- he saw that
none of the children under his sway were spoiled to save the bark from being
knocked off the aforesaid 'birch', which was either a hazel or a willow switch.
He was known far and wide as a most competent man to subjugate a refractory
school and his services were much in demand along that line. But aside form
his unquestioned ability to administer corporal punishment to the queen's
taste, he was successful in teaching the young idea how to shoot. He was,
indeed, a terror to evil doers in the school-room, but notwithstanding the
severity of the flagellations which disobedient pupils received for not minding
their books, those who obeyed him made good progress in their studies under
his teaching. Many a boy that Mr. Campbell flogged in the school-room, resolved
in his mind, that when he grew up he would lick him to within an inch of
his life; but when he reached the years of maturity his animosity toward
the old teacher had died out, and if he were standing by his grave today,
instead of the resentment of boyhood days in his heart, he would say, in
subdued voice: "I forgive him. Peace to his ashes!"
The frame-work of Joseph Shearer's house in Whitestown is that of the old
school-house in which Mr. Campbell taught.
During the term I attended school in Whitestown, a doe came to school from
Uncle Billy Martin's, along with Mary Jane, Satiah Ann and Marion. It came
in the mornings and would browse around the school-house during the day and
go home with them in the evenings, as regularly as they came and went. Harvest
hands at Mr. Martin's had caught the fawn in a wheat field. While it was
tame, yet it was not so docile as the little lamb that another Mary, somewhere
else took with her to school. This little deer had a way of resenting the
attentions of the boys and girls, which gave notice to them not to waste
undue familiarity upon her. From that time to this I have not seen a domesticated
deer. Robert White of Whitestown taught the Whitestown school in 1857. Robert
McLure, lawyer and poet, who died in Butler several years ago and now sleeps
in Mt. Nebo graveyard, was the largest boy in school the term I attended
in Whitestown.
Prospect Schools Seventy Years Ago
By the Rev. H.W. Roth, D.D.
My brother, the Rev. D. Luther Roth, D.D., and the Hon. A.W. McCullough have
asked me to tell something of the schools in dear old Prospect during the
40's of the last century. By reason of Mr. McCullough's painstaking and efficient
effort to bring before us the historical past in his most interesting address,
and by reason of the untiring interest and energy of my brother in projecting
and urging the Old Home Week celebration and in carrying it to its very
successful completion. I can not find it in my heart to do otherwise than
make an attempt to comply with their desire in this matter.
Unfortunately after so many years memory grows hazy and things come wildering
along somewhat indistinctly. One may forget what might be of interest, and
possibly mistakes may be made in trying to set out in correct order the things
of long, long ago. So it may be in making record of incidents pertaining
to the schools of that period.
In Prospect there were no buildings erected for school purposes only.
Subscription schools were then in vogue. Some one would offer to teach, and
the parents would agee to pay so much per month for the instruction of each
of their children. For two or tthree months of the winter the larger youth
attended school. The small children had their turn in the summer.
The first school which I faintly recall was held in the Union church of which
note is elsewhere made in this volume. The teacher was G.P. Robinson who
occpied the residence where Dr. L.M. Roth now lives. The pupils came up in
classes, and the crack in the floor where two boards joined, constituted
the line at which those who made recitations had to "toe the mark."
Several pillars sustained the ceiling, and at recitation some of the well-grown
boys surreptitiously attempted to climb the pillars. When dismissing the
class one day Mr. Robinson asked one of these boys whether he would like
to "toe it up" the pillar. He said that he would and proceeded to mount toward
the ceiling. When he was fairly up, Mr. Robinson called his "Cat o'nine tails"
into play and the lad came down a good deal faster than he had gone up. That
must have been quite early in the 40's.
"Aunt Polly Craig", as she was universally known, kept school in the same
Union church. She was a dear old lady, gentle, refined and patient beyond
expression. With her afflicted sister Jane, she occupied a little cabin which
stood near where Mrs. Jones now resides.
One of her classes was learning the "letters". We stood around her knee on
which lay a page which contained the alphabet in both large and small letters
from "a" to "zed" or "izzard". She pointed to a letter, gave its name and
the whole class in unison repeated after her the name of the letter. Eventually
we learned our letters.
One day a "church mouse" came out from under the base-board and diligently
nibbled at the crumbs which the children had let fall from their dinners.
Willie Brower stood next to myself. The mouse caught my eye, I nudged Willie
and he some one else until presently the entire class was faithfully saying
"A", "B", etc., as "Aunt Polly" announced but the eyes of all saw only the
mouse as it wandered about looking up its dinner.
At Christmas "Aunt Polly" gave the school a treat. Mr. John Jones who lived
where the Lutheran Pastor's Home now stands, brought in a sled the baskets
of rosy cheeked apples which constituted the "treat." I can yet hear the
merry jingle of the sleigh bells as Mr. Jones drove into the church yard.
The larger pupils were served first, so many apples each. The remaining apples
were thrown from the basket into a corner of the church and the little folks
had a scramble for what they received. All had a treat but some got more
apples than did others on that occasion.
The next place where school was held was a hewed-log building located not
far from where in later years the "Town Scales" were placed. The seats were
rude. There was not an overplus of light, but being summer, the open door
let in a fair supply. It had a "puncheon" floor. In its center several of
these puncheons were loose and underneath its former owner stored his winter
supply of potatoes.
Mr. Thomas Forester was the teacher. He boarded at the "Phipps Hotel". On
the hot summer days after dinner Mr. Forester betimes grew quite drowsy and
wearily stretched himself upon a bench to rest. As the sound of his breathing
rose and fell in regular cadence, we little ones would steal tip-toe out-doors
and have a bit of play until the rap at the window again called us to "books".
If a mischievous lad grew too "frisky" and tried the patience of the teacher
beyond endurance, a couple of puncheons were lifted and by the "nape of the
neck" the culprit was consigned until penitent to this seemingly worse than
the "Black Hole of Calcutta."
One of the Cumberland boys, possibly Arthur, could make chestnut or willow
whistles, and his talent was in frequent call, since all of us plead each
for a whistle.
In 1846, upon a parcel of ground bought from Mr. James McGowan, the town
built its first school house. It was brick and of one story. At the south
end was a large black-board. High desks on opposite sides stood next the
wall, one side for the big girls and the other for the big boys. Nearer the
stove, seats were placed for the little children. For that day, it was a
comfortable building and showed the interest which the citizens of Prospect
then took, and for that matter, have always taken in the education of their
children.
Mr.James Cummings who moved from Mifflin, Pa., ws a teacher whom I recall
with special affection. Among other things he taught some of us to make drawings
from outlines which himself furnished.
He was a good citizen and deeply interested in fruit growing, apples
particularly. To this day many of the trees of his planting are to found
in and near Prospect. A little dog was the enevitable companion of Mr. Cummings
when about out-door duties. The dog's name was "Tyro." In his pockets there
seemed an exhaustless supply of dried fruit of which he was always eating.
Peace to the memory of this gentleman.
Mr.Ford S. Dodds also taught in the brick school house. He loved music and
taught the school many songs: "The Bell Doth Toll", "A Southerly Wind from
a Cloudy Sky," etc. Alvin C. Daniels was another teacher there. His forte
was "Runninghand." Even at this time his formation of the capital "D" comes
quite clearly before my eyes.
Sometimes we were allowed to "study out loud." Then every follow went to
work at the top of his voice. The noise was "great". At a distance the school
house must have seemed like a huge "bum-bees" nest, recently stirred up,
and every bee uniting in strong and vigorous protest against the invasion
of their home.
"Readin, Riten and "Rithmetic", the three "R's" were the principal studies.
"No licken, no larnen" was an acceptable maxim, and generally of daily
application. Sometimes our bare feet were strapped as we danced to music
of our own making. Sometimes the ruler well laid on upon the open palm evoked
heart-breaking yells. Sometimes the old fashioned rod played the prominent
part in teaching the young "idea how to shoot."
Spelling took up much of the time. Once a week "sides" were chosen and that
was a proud pupil who, at these contests stood alone, having "spelled down"
the rest of the school. Betimes neighboring schools were challenged and at
night the combatants met. Leaders or captains were chosen who selected the
"sides" and with breathless interest the "spelling out" of the contestants
was matched until one side or the other had been vanquished. Not then as
in these days was spelling a "lost art."
Mr.Miller also was one of my teachers. At Christmas the "big boys" contumaciously
agreed that he must either treat the school or be "barred out." Coming quite
early, they closed and fastened the door and the windows and when the teacher
arrived he was presented with a written instrument which set forth their
demands. Vainly he pounded the door and tried the windows. The "big girls"
and the little folks inside were trembling with terror. Climbing upon the
roof and covering the chimney did not smoke the doughty warriors out or drive
them from their purpose. Some of us lads were let out as Paul "by a window",
and had fine coasting in McGowns's meadow, west of the Franklin road.
Eventually the teacher agreed to the conditions imposed and myself with a
couple of other lads were sent to Mr. William Dick's and dragged a sack of
apples on a sled from his farm east of Prospect to the school house, being
almost frozen in the expedition. Candies and apples constituted the treat
and peace was restored, though it sems to me some of the leaders in the "barring
out" had their jackets dusted by the irate teacher before the matter became
a "closed issue."
Cobbs' Speller, the English Reader, McGuffy's Readers, the Western Calculator,
Kirkham's Grammer, Pelton's Outline Maps were some of the later text books.
Goose quills were made into pens by the teache. Thes were used in the earliest
days, and to make a good pen was no mean attainment. Later, steel pens came
into use. On slips of paper copy was set by the teacher. Among these were,
"Evil communications corrupt good manners". "Birds of a feather flock together",
etc., which the young writers tried to imitate after their full and weary
course in straight lines and "pot hooks".
The Outline maps contained no names. Those were supplied from a separate
book in which the names of capitals, rivers, mountains, seas, oceans, etc.,
were brought together so that they might be sung. For instance, -- "State
of Maine, Augusta, on the Kennebeck River", "Pennsylvania, Harrisburg, on
the Susquehanna". The teacher or some apt pupil pointed to the places and
the "jography" class sang the proper context. It fixed the map with its names
and places in the memory and was lots of fun to the singers.
We played "Circus", "Anthony Over", "Paddle Ball", "Sock Ball", Corner Ball",
"Gable Ball", etc., and had plenty of sport and exercise, to say nothing
of the old apple tree in the corner of the school yard whose branches were
crowded with youngsters eating the fruit as it barely showed from the blossoms
and sadly affected our "tummies" and distressed our good mothers, beside
the gathering of hickory nuts and chestnuts in their season, wth chasing
after "grinnies" and stoning hornet and "bum bees nests.
After the 40ties, among those teachers were Cyrus H. Dunlap and Jared B.
Wallace; the former became a prominent clergyman in the Presbyterian Church,
his last pastorate being at Bellevue, near Pittsburgh, and the latter, for
a time a preacher in the Methodist Church and later for many years an elder
of the Presbyterian Church. Mr. Wallace was a delighted visitor at Old Home
Week. They were fine teachers, noble men, and left a marked impess upon their
scholars. In 1911 both of them were called to their reward in the better
world. Mr. Isaac Black was the first County School Superintendent after that
office was instituted by the laws of the State of Pennsylvania.
Compared with the complete equipments and the palatial school buildings of
today the furniture was rude and the facilities few and of inferior character.
Yet the teachers were generally conscientious in the discharge of their duties
and their pupils secured substantial education. The terms seldom exceeded
three months in the year. Wages were small, the teachers often "boarding
around" among their patrons and thus securing part of the pay for their services.
"Fads" there were none. The essentials were brought to the minds of the pupils
and they were forced to not a little thinking of their own in order to master
the study to which their time was devoted. We do not say "The former days
were better than these days" but all things considered, the things attained
by the children in those days were not inferior for the purposes of actual
life to the things attained by the children enjoying the facilities of these
days. |